One of the fun things about being involved in "multi-vendor" solutions is when you recognize moments of amazing sanity as they occur. One such moment of amazing sanity is occurring next week when ODVA (aka Rockwell / Allen-Bradley) and Modbus supporters (aka Schneider-Electric / Modicon / SquareD / Telemecanique) sit down to discuss how to integrate Modbus devices into the ODVA Ethernet/IP and CIP network systems. Of course there must be some interesting hidden politics behind this move - and I somewhat light-heartedly believe that perhaps French Schneider-Electric sees joining with the Americans (Rockwell/ODVA) as the lesser of two evils when compared to joining with the Germans (Siemens/PNO).
Check out: ODVA Call For Members: Modbus Integration JSIG The kick-off meeting for the Modbus JSIG runs from Thursday, May 10, 11:00 AM to Friday, May 11, 04:00 PM
Side-stepping the marketing fluff and platitudes of a brighter future such meetings evoke, small third-party suppliers and the folks on the plant floor can expect the following benefits. Regardless of the directly stated goals of ODVA, Rockwell, or Schneider-Electric, small vendors will implement solutions that include these abilities:
- Vendors making Ethernet Modbus/TCP products will have a simpler "first step" to adding full ODVA/CIP support without the somewhat overwhelming task of 100% conversion of a word-array device model into hundreds (or thousands) of CIP objects.
- ControlLogix PLC will be able to connect through Ethernet-to-Serial devices to multi-drops of Modbus/RTU slaves. For example a user with a dozen small Modbus/RTU PID loop controllers will be able to add an Ethernet-to-Serial device to read via Modbus and cyclically produce a small block of word data from each loop controller over Ethernet.
- HART, Bluetooth, ZigBee and other new technologies which offer Modbus interfaces will find a instant place as sensors and I/O within CIP and Rockwell systems.
- Since Siemens, GE-Fanuc, Omron, Mitsubishi and most major PLC brands offer some method to act as Modbus slaves, users with any of these PLC will be able to integrate them within the CIP Producer/Consumer system.
- I started working with ODVA Ethernet/IP almost 8 years ago and still as-of today the legacy PLC5E, SLC5, and serial MicroLogix (the old PCCC-based PLC) don't have effective inclusion within CIP Producer/Consumer systems. Since the device model of PCCC PLC shares much in common with Modbus PLC, it is a very small enhancement to add a similar support for AB PLC - perhaps AB will actually extend this to future firmware updates to Ethernet-based PLC. In fact, since my Digi One IAP code already allows Modbus masters to query DF1 and CSPv4 slaves as-if Modbus slaves, as soon as Digi adds Ethernet-to-Modbus support per this JSIG's output users of older AB PLC will gain access to CIP Producer/Consumer systems indirectly as honorary Modbus slaves.
- Today legacy Modbus and Modbus/TCP systems lack any simple form of multicast producer/consumer exchange. While the IDA protocol offers this, IDA is so many orders of magnitude more complex (and resource hungry) than simple Modbus as to become really an "unrelated" protocol. Any specification that defines a "server interface" naturally implies a corresponding "client interface". So although this ODVA JSIG is not planning to define how Modbus "peers" could use multicast to exchange cyclic data, the end result will be a fairly natural and multi-vendor method to do this. So while I doubt many pure Modbus/TCP products would implement ODVA protocols just to gain this multicast exchange, any products which add the CIP support anyway will naturally add the last few bits of code required to enable pure Modbus-to-Modbus multicast via the ODVA mechanism.
- Taking the above point to its natural conclusion means Modbus/TCP masters which implement the Modbus JSIG's "server" function will also gain a mechanism to access CIP Producer/Consumer systems. Even if the ODVA JSIG doesn't cover how to do this, natural methods will be inferred, produced, and copied by vendors to make this a fairly common new product feature.